Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for sending a cleaner into my sister’s apartment while she was traveling?

AITA category photographAITA

My sister gave me a key to her apartment so I could water plants during a three-week trip. On my second visit, I noticed food scraps in the kitchen bin and a strong smell.

I took out the trash but also saw dust, dishes and laundry around the apartment. She was returning the night before starting a new job, so I hired my cleaner for two hours as a welcome-home surprise.

The cleaner washed clothes from the floor, reorganized toiletries and placed papers into folders. Nothing was discarded.

My sister came home and panicked because she could not find a notebook containing work ideas. It was inside a folder on a shelf. She says the key was for plants, not permission to let a stranger handle her private belongings.

I say the apartment was unpleasant and I paid for a thoughtful service. She says the smell ended when I removed the trash and everything after that was judgment.

The cleaner had sent me before-and-after photographs for her records. My sister was visible in framed pictures in several shots.

I deleted the photographs when asked. My sister changed the lock before unpacking.

Discussion

5 community replies

Plant access did not authorize admitting a stranger to wash, organize and photograph your sister’s private belongings.

Removing forgotten food waste was a reasonable response to an immediate smell during a three-week absence.

The necessary trash removal and the optional whole-apartment cleaning were separate decisions with different consent needs.

Did the cleaner retain any before-and-after photographs after you deleted your copies?

Confirm all cleaner copies are deleted, apologize without calling the apartment unpleasant and accept that key access has ended.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →