Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for selling my friend’s handmade table for more than I paid and keeping the profit?

AITA category photographAITA

A friend made a small dining table while learning woodworking. She sold it to me for $300, saying she had spent nearly that much on materials but wanted it in a home she knew.

Two years later, I moved into a smaller apartment. I listed the table online for $700, expecting negotiation. A buyer paid the full price the same day.

My friend saw the listing after it sold. She says the original price was a friendship price and I should give her at least part of the $400 difference. I say I owned the table and took the risk that it might not sell at all.

She had never said resale was restricted. She had, however, asked me to contact her if I stopped using it because she might want it back.

I remembered that request only after accepting the buyer’s payment. I could still cancel the sale, but the buyer had already rented a van.

I sent my friend photographs of the table in its new home, thinking she would appreciate that it was valued. She replied with the original invoice marked “materials only.”

Discussion

5 community replies

A completed sale normally transferred the table to you without an automatic obligation to share later resale gains.

Keeping legal ownership and honoring a friendship understanding are separate questions; the missing contact is the central breach.

Your friend asked for first contact if you stopped using it, and the materials-only invoice shows the discount was substantial.

Did she ask to buy it back at your original price, or merely to hear from you before any resale?

Offer her a meaningful share of the gain or another remedy, and acknowledge that you forgot the promised first opportunity.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →