AITA for returning my fiancé’s family ring to his mother during our break?
AITAMy fiancé and I agreed to take a one-month break after repeated arguments. I removed my engagement ring but did not end the engagement.
His mother asked whether the family ring was safe. Without telling him, I returned it to her because I did not want responsibility for an heirloom while our future was uncertain.
Two weeks later, my fiancé and I reconciled. He asked for the ring back, but his mother refused, saying our relationship had proven too unstable for it.
He says I let his mother become judge of our engagement. I say the ring belonged to his family and returning it was the most respectful option during a break.
I could have placed it in a safe-deposit box. His mother had suggested that too, but I chose direct return because I wanted one less connection to manage.
We are still engaged. The ring is locked in a safe neither of us controls.