Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for returning a borrowed costume before my friend’s performance?

AITA category photographAITA

A friend lent me a vintage coat for a themed party, with the agreement that I would return it Sunday evening.

On Saturday, she was unexpectedly cast in a small theater role and asked for the coat back by noon Sunday. I had planned a photo session that afternoon and said I would keep our original return time.

She came to my apartment Sunday morning, but I did not answer. I returned the coat at 7 p.m. as promised. She had already performed in a substitute jacket that did not match the production photographs.

I say a loan deadline should mean something and her last-minute need did not erase my plans. She says the owner standing outside asking for her property mattered more than a casual photo session.

The session could have used another coat, but I liked how this one looked. Her new role paid nothing; my photographs were also just for fun.

The coat came back clean and on time. She has not lent me anything since.

Discussion

4 community replies

You planned around an agreed Sunday-evening return, and her new performance need arose unexpectedly.

Meeting the original deadline does not fully answer whether a borrower should refuse a reasonable early return request from the owner.

The owner came in person before use and asked for the coat; ignoring the door prioritized optional photographs over her property.

Could you have completed the photo session Saturday or used another garment Sunday?

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →