Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for reporting a little free library after its owner removed my books?

AITA category photographAITA

A homeowner on my street built a small book cabinet beside the sidewalk. The sign said, “Take a book, leave a book.” I contributed a box of mystery novels and checked back a few days later.

All of mine were gone. The homeowner told me she had recycled them because they smelled strongly of smoke and made the other books smell too. I had bought them secondhand and had not noticed.

I asked her to reimburse me. She said donations were not guaranteed shelf space and pointed to a new note requesting clean, dry books.

I then reported the cabinet to the city because it extended several inches into the public right-of-way. An inspector required her to move it behind her fence while the permit question was reviewed.

She says I used enforcement to punish a decision about her own cabinet. I say public space rules apply whether or not the library is popular.

Before the disagreement, I had walked past that cabinet for two years without reporting it. I searched the city website only after she refused to pay me.

The cabinet now faces her yard, so passersby cannot reach it. My books are still gone, and the street has gained several conversations about me.

Discussion

5 community replies

You tolerated the cabinet for years and reported it only after a personal dispute, making the code complaint plainly retaliatory.

The right-of-way issue may be technically valid, but a valid rule can still be invoked for a vindictive reason.

Smoke odor can transfer in an enclosed cabinet, and a volunteer steward must be able to remove unsuitable donations.

Did the cabinet have any posted donation standards when you left the books, or did the clean-book notice appear afterward?

Withdraw any objection you can, apologize for escalating, and ask before leaving a large donation at a volunteer-run exchange.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →