Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for replacing our choir accompanist with a recording after she raised her fee?

AITA category photographAITA

A pianist has accompanied our community choir for four years. Two months before the winter concert, she said her fee would increase from $300 to $500 because rehearsals had grown longer.

Our budget could cover it only by reducing costume funds. I recorded the pianist during one rehearsal, then used editing software to create accompaniment tracks for the concert pieces.

I told her we no longer needed her services. I did not mention the recording until she attended rehearsal and heard the choir singing over her own playing.

She says a recording made for practice was never offered as a replacement product. I say the choir paid her for that rehearsal and the tracks let a volunteer group survive a sudden increase.

The singers dislike following fixed tempos, and two solos had to be simplified. The costume budget remains intact.

I could have asked whether she would license the recordings or negotiate fewer rehearsals. I avoided that conversation because the tracks gave me leverage I had already created.

Her hands will be heard at the concert. Her name is not in the program.

Discussion

5 community replies

Payment for a rehearsal did not clearly grant permission to turn the pianist’s performance into a reusable replacement for her services.

The fixed tracks also reduced the choir’s flexibility, so preserving costume funds was not the only artistic tradeoff.

A substantial fee increase challenged a volunteer budget, but negotiation and scope changes remained available.

Was the rehearsal recording announced and consented to, and did any agreement address future playback?

Stop using the tracks unless she agrees to terms, credit her work and renegotiate live accompaniment or a lawful alternative.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →