Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for replacing my mother’s grocery order with cheaper brands without telling her?

AITA category photographAITA

My mother sends me her grocery list and card details because online ordering frustrates her. She prefers the same brands she has bought for years.

This week, the store offered a large discount if the order contained fifteen house-brand items. I replaced pasta, cereal, soap and several other products to qualify, saving $38.

I kept the savings as a delivery fee because I spent an hour building the order and driving it to her. We had never discussed payment; she usually cooks dinner for me when I visit.

She noticed every substitution and asked why the card charge was lower than the receipt total I had texted. I admitted that my receipt showed the pre-discount amount and that I had treated the difference as mine.

She says I changed her shopping and paid myself from her discount without permission. I say she received equivalent groceries for the amount she expected to spend.

Two products did not suit her, so I exchanged them. The return credit went back to her card.

She now phones the store and reads her list to an employee, even though the call takes longer than asking me did.

Discussion

5 community replies

You altered products and concealed the actual charge so you could create a fee your mother had never agreed to pay.

Equivalent groceries were not guaranteed, as shown by the two returns and her established product preferences.

Ordering and delivery took real time, but compensation needed a direct conversation rather than ownership of a hidden discount.

Did your mother set a maximum budget, or did she specifically instruct you to buy the listed brands regardless of price?

Return the $38, agree on any future delivery fee in advance and make substitutions only with her approval.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →