Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for replacing my grandmother’s chair and discarding the old one?

AITA category photographAITA

My grandmother had used the same armchair for decades. Its cushions sagged, one leg wobbled and the fabric was worn through.

While she stayed with my aunt for a week, I bought a powered recliner and arranged delivery. The store hauled the old chair away for disposal.

My grandmother returned and refused to sit in the new chair. She says the old one held memories of my grandfather and she would have chosen repair over replacement.

I say the chair was uncomfortable and increasingly difficult for her to stand from. She had complained about it often but rejected every shopping trip.

The store had offered to leave the old chair by the curb. I chose removal because I knew she would insist on keeping both if she saw it.

The recliner makes standing easier. She sits instead on a dining chair and keeps the new one covered with a sheet.

I improved the function of her room by removing the object that made it hers.

Discussion

4 community replies

The worn, unstable chair caused practical problems, and the powered replacement may make standing easier.

Complaining about discomfort was not consent to dispose of the chair during her absence.

You permanently discarded a deeply personal object precisely because you knew its owner would refuse that choice.

Could the old chair have been stored temporarily while repair and replacement options were tested?

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →