AITA for replacing a volunteer driver after he smoked in our borrowed van?
AITAI coordinate weekend deliveries for a food pantry. A volunteer named Eric usually drives a van loaned by a local business.
After one route, the van smelled strongly of smoke. Eric admitted smoking beside the open driver’s door during a break but said he never smoked inside.
The business owner complained and asked us to prevent it happening again. I removed Eric from driving and assigned him warehouse work without first discussing the change.
Eric says he has driven reliably for two years and could have agreed to a clear no-smoking-near-the-van rule. He relies on driving because lifting boxes aggravates an old shoulder problem.
I told him he could volunteer at the sign-in desk instead. That role has fewer hours and no mileage reimbursement.
The owner did not demand Eric’s removal, only that the smell not return. I made the stricter choice because losing the van would disrupt every route.
The van has smelled normal since. Eric has stopped volunteering, and three routes now end later because the replacement driver is available only in the afternoons.