Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for removing my former stepfather’s smart-lock access after my mother divorced him?

AITA category photographAITA

My mother and her husband Paul separated after eleven years. Paul never lived with me, but he had a code to my apartment because he often walked my dog when I worked late.

The divorce became bitter. My mother asked me to remove his code, saying she did not want him able to enter any family home. I did so without telling him.

The next evening, Paul came for the dog at our usual time. His code failed while the dog was barking inside. I was in a meeting and did not see his calls for nearly an hour.

Paul says our dog-walking arrangement was between us and that I used my mother’s divorce to erase a relationship he believed we still had. My mother says maintaining access would have felt like choosing his side.

I did want Paul to keep walking the dog. I planned to offer him a temporary code once the divorce calmed down, but I never told either of them that.

He returned my spare leash and said I should hire someone. My mother was relieved, although she had never visited my apartment while Paul was there.

Changing the code was my right. Letting him discover the end of an eleven-year family routine at a locked door was also my choice.

Discussion

5 community replies

You control access to your home, and a contentious divorce is a sensible time to review every existing door code.

You expected Paul to perform the same favor while secretly disabling the access required to do it. That made the locked door an avoidable message.

The problem is not that Paul retained a permanent right to enter; it is that the narrator ended an active arrangement without notice.

Had either your mother or Paul described a safety concern, or was removing the code solely a loyalty request?

Apologize directly and decide whether you want an independent relationship with Paul instead of leaving that decision inside your mother’s divorce.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

Useful guidance

Separate emergency access from permission to visit. Explain when someone may use the key, whether they should contact you first and what you will do if the arrangement stops working. A useful boundary describes an action you can take.

How to set expectations for family visits and spare keys →

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →