AITA for rejecting my son’s apology because he copied a template?
AITAMy twelve-year-old insulted a classmate in a group message. I required him to write an apology before using his phone again.
He produced a thoughtful note acknowledging the comment and its impact. I searched one sentence and found the wording on an apology website.
I tore up the note and extended his phone restriction for another week, saying copied remorse was not remorse.
He says he used the template because he did not know how to begin, then changed most of it. The classmate had already accepted the apology after receiving a photograph from him.
I contacted the classmate’s parent and said a new apology would follow. My son says I invalidated the repair he had made to teach a lesson about composition.
The second note was fully original and much shorter. The classmate replied, “You already said sorry.”
I wanted authentic words. I made the recipient receive the conflict twice.