Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for rejecting a handmade bookshelf after my friend changed the wood?

AITA category photographAITA

A friend who builds furniture agreed to make me a bookshelf for $600. We discussed pale maple and simple square edges. I paid half upfront.

When she delivered it, the shelf was made from darker walnut with rounded corners. She said her maple supplier had canceled and the walnut normally cost more, so I was receiving an upgrade.

I refused delivery and asked for my deposit back. She says the shelf fits every measurement and the stronger material benefits me. I say color was the main reason I commissioned rather than bought one ready-made.

She had sent a message saying there was a “material issue” and would update me soon. I was traveling and did not reply. She proceeded because the delivery date was approaching.

Another buyer offered $700 but wanted the bottom shelf altered. My friend says returning my deposit would leave her earning less after rework.

I have left the final $300 unpaid. The bookshelf sits wrapped in her garage.

She made a more expensive object than I ordered. That fact has not made it the object I wanted.

Discussion

4 community replies

Wood color and edge style were explicit design choices, not minor substitutions, so refusing a materially different commission was reasonable.

Higher material value does not automatically increase value to the customer when appearance was the purpose of commissioning.

The supplier failure created a real problem, but the maker needed affirmative approval before using a visibly different material.

Did the written quote specify maple and square edges, or were those details only discussed verbally?

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →