Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for refusing to share doorbell footage after my neighbor called my camera invasive?

AITA category photographAITA

My neighbor has complained for months that my doorbell camera captures too much of the shared hallway. I adjusted the motion zone, but its view still includes part of his doorway.

Last week, a delivery disappeared from outside his apartment. He asked whether my camera had recorded anyone carrying it away.

I checked and found a clear clip. I told him the camera had footage but refused to send it unless he acknowledged in writing that the device served a legitimate purpose.

He said he would not endorse surveillance he still considered excessive. I kept the clip and told him to ask building management.

Management later requested it, and I provided it. By then, the delivery company’s quick claim window had closed, although my neighbor can still pursue the matter through its normal process.

I say I preserved evidence and followed a formal request. He says I used his missing package to demand ideological surrender.

For months I wanted proof that the camera could help him too. When that proof arrived, I made assistance conditional on him saying I had been right.

Discussion

5 community replies

You had relevant footage and withheld it to force a statement unrelated to recovering the neighbor’s package.

Eventually giving management the clip preserved it, but the delay still imposed a practical cost on the person seeking it.

His ongoing privacy concern can remain valid even when the camera happens to record useful evidence.

Did building policy require management to mediate footage requests, or could you have shared the single clip directly?

Provide relevant incident clips promptly through the approved channel and resolve the camera angle dispute separately with management.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →