AITA for refusing to reimburse my friend after she left before the bill arrived?
AITAFive friends shared dinner. One friend left early for a train and handed me $60, saying it should cover her meal, tax and tip.
Her portion came to $42. The group decided to order dessert after she left, and I applied her extra $18 to the total rather than returning it.
She asked the next day for the remainder. I said her payment had gone into the shared bill and nobody tracked exact change during group dinners.
She says she did track it by giving me a specific amount and trusting me to settle her portion. I say the dessert was shared by the table she had joined, even if she was gone.
She had not ordered or eaten dessert. I still had the itemized receipt and could calculate the exact difference.
I later sent her $10 as a compromise. She returned it with a request for the full $18.