AITA for refusing to recommend an intern after she corrected me in front of a client?
AITAI supervised an intern named Tessa for four months. Her work was accurate, punctual and often better organized than our permanent staff’s.
During a client meeting, I quoted last quarter’s sales growth as 18 percent. Tessa interrupted and said the final figure was 11 percent because returns had been entered late. She was correct. I thanked her and continued.
At the end of the internship, Tessa asked me for a recommendation. I declined, saying she needed to improve professional judgment and should have corrected me privately.
She replied that the client was about to make a budget decision using the wrong figure and that waiting would have let the error stand. She had tried to catch my eye first, which I did not notice.
My manager says I should write an accurate letter mentioning both her strong work and the communication concern. I do not want my name attached to someone who may contradict a supervisor publicly again.
The client later thanked our team for catching the discrepancy before the proposal. I included that praise in my own project summary.
Tessa corrected the number. I retained the credit for a transparent meeting and denied her the reference that could explain who made it transparent.