Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for refusing to dim my floodlight during my neighbor’s stargazing fundraiser?

AITA category photographAITA

My backyard floodlight turns on automatically at dusk. I installed it after several packages disappeared from our side gate.

My neighbor planned a ticketed stargazing fundraiser for the local school on her lawn. A week beforehand, she asked me to switch the light off for two hours so guests could see the sky.

I refused because I would be away that evening and did not want the side path dark. She offered to aim a temporary camera at my gate and pay for a battery light that faced downward. I still declined.

During the event, the floodlight washed out part of the view. The group moved to a park, losing nearly forty minutes and several families with young children.

I say my home security is not an event resource she can schedule. She says I rejected every practical compromise because I disliked her charging admission on a residential street.

That part is true. I thought a failed event would discourage future crowds.

The school still received the money. My neighbor now closes her curtains before dusk, though the floodlight points away from her windows.

Discussion

5 community replies

You were entitled to consider the security of your side gate while away, especially after prior package losses.

Your neighbor offered two concrete security substitutes, and you admit the refusal was partly intended to make her event fail.

Disliking a ticketed neighborhood event was a separate concern that should have been raised directly rather than through the lighting decision.

Could the floodlight have been temporarily redirected downward without leaving the path or gate unlit?

Offer to test a shield or lower angle before any future event and discuss crowd concerns separately from legitimate lighting needs.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →