AITA for refusing a delivery driver access to our building restroom?
AITAI was covering the front desk in my apartment building when a delivery driver asked to use the lobby restroom. Building policy limits it to residents, guests and staff.
I refused and pointed him toward a café two blocks away. He said he had several packages still on the cart and could not leave them unattended.
He asked again, and I repeated the policy. A resident entering the lobby offered to sign him in as a guest, but I rejected that because they did not actually know each other.
The driver left with the packages and returned twenty minutes later. Several residents received late-delivery notices even though they had been home.
They say I enforced a minor rule without basic compassion. I say the desk log and restroom key exist because strangers cannot simply enter private areas.
The restroom door is visible from the desk, and I could have held the cart while he used it. I did not want to become responsible for his packages.
The building manager later said staff may use discretion for working delivery personnel. The policy had never included that sentence in writing.