Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for putting my mother on speakerphone without telling her?

AITA category photographAITA

My mother called while my partner and I were driving to dinner. I answered through the car and put the call on speaker without saying my partner was listening.

She began complaining that my partner never helps at family gatherings and said she hoped I would come alone to the holidays. My partner heard every word.

I interrupted and revealed that we were both in the car. My mother hung up. My partner now refuses to attend the holiday meal, and my mother says I deliberately exposed a private conversation to embarrass her.

I say people should not say things about someone that they would not say in front of them. My partner says that principle does not excuse letting the call continue long enough for the criticism to become specific.

The car display had shown the call was routed through the speakers, but my mother could not see it. I could have announced who was present in the first sentence.

Part of me wanted my partner to hear that I had not exaggerated my mother’s hostility. I obtained proof by making both of them participants in a conversation only one knew was shared.

Discussion

5 community replies

You concealed that another person was listening and allowed your mother to disclose views she reasonably believed were private.

The rule against speaking behind someone’s back does not grant secret-listening permission; it calls for a direct conversation.

Your mother’s comments were unkind and directly affected your partner, so the underlying conflict needed to be addressed openly.

How long did you let her speak before revealing the speakerphone, and were there earlier chances to interrupt?

Apologize separately to both people for the setup, then tell your mother directly what treatment of your partner you will require.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →