Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for publishing my former friend’s anonymous advice letter?

AITA category photographAITA

A former friend once emailed me asking for advice about leaving a long relationship. The friendship later ended for unrelated reasons.

I now edit a small community newsletter. For a relationships issue, I adapted her email into an anonymous advice letter, changing names, ages and the city.

She recognized several distinctive details and contacted me. She says anonymity does not matter when the writer recognizes herself and never agreed to publication.

I say the situation is common, no reader could identify her and the advice may help others. She says I used access gained through friendship as free material after the friendship stopped protecting her.

The issue had already been distributed. I removed the online version but kept printed copies at local cafés because retrieving them would draw attention.

One changed detail made the fictional writer look more financially dependent than my friend had been. She says even the disguise misrepresented her.

The column received more responses than anything else in the issue.

Discussion

4 community replies

A private request for advice did not become publishable material when the friendship ended, even after surface details changed.

The inaccurate financial detail shows anonymization also changed the moral framing, not merely identity markers.

Generalized dilemmas can help readers, but the source person’s recognizability to herself still matters ethically.

Could the column have been built from a fully fictional composite rather than adapting one identifiable private message?

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →