AITA for painting our shared fence with glossy paint while my neighbor was away?
AITAMy neighbor and I agreed to repaint the fence between our patios the same dark green it had always been. She left town before the work began.
The paint store had the color only in glossy finish. The contractor said waiting would cost another callout fee, so I approved the gloss.
The color matches, but the fence now reflects afternoon light into my neighbor’s kitchen and shows every uneven board. She says finish was part of the appearance we agreed to preserve.
I say the agreement named a color, not a sheen, and I paid the contractor on time. She wants my side repainted too so the fence looks consistent from above.
Matte paint would have arrived two days later. The callout fee was $80; repainting will cost much more.
I saved the smaller fee by making the only person present the only person whose preference counted.