Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for locking our balcony after my roommate’s cat escaped?

AITA category photographAITA

My roommate’s indoor cat slipped through the balcony railing and reached a neighboring balcony. We recovered her after an hour.

The next day, I installed a keyed lock on the balcony door and kept the key. I said the balcony would remain closed until my roommate added secure screening.

My roommate uses the balcony to dry clothes and grow herbs. She offered to keep the cat in her bedroom while outside, but I refused because someone could forget.

She says I cannot unilaterally block a shared part of the apartment. I say another escape could end worse, and the cat’s safety outweighs convenience.

The landlord had approved temporary pet netting, but delivery would take five days. I kept the balcony locked for all five.

During that time, damp laundry hung inside and the herbs wilted behind the glass. The cat stayed safe.

The new netting is now installed. My roommate has asked the landlord for a second key to the lock I bought.

Discussion

4 community replies

A recent escape justified an immediate temporary measure while approved screening was on the way.

The safety goal was valid, but the strictest possible rule was not necessarily the only safe temporary option.

Keeping the only key denied all supervised balcony use and made you sole controller of a shared amenity.

Could the lock have remained accessible while the cat was confined during each balcony use?

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →