Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for locking our apartment rooftop after my neighbor held a photoshoot there?

AITA category photographAITA

Residents in my building share a small rooftop with chairs and potted plants. I am the volunteer who holds the maintenance key.

One neighbor used the roof for a two-hour engagement photoshoot. The photographer moved furniture, and three light stands blocked the narrow path to the stairs. Nobody had asked the building committee.

The next morning, I locked the rooftop and posted that access was suspended until residents agreed on booking rules. I did not consult the committee first.

That weekend was unusually cool, and several families had planned dinner upstairs. They blamed the neighbor, who says I turned one crowded afternoon into punishment for the entire building.

Nothing was damaged. The photographer returned the chairs and removed the equipment. My concern was that the next event might be larger, and I wanted rules before precedent became expectation.

The committee met five days later and adopted a two-hour booking limit. It also told me I had never been authorized to close the roof except for a maintenance hazard.

The new rule resembles what I wanted. The locked door was how I made everyone discuss it on my schedule.

Discussion

5 community replies

A commercial-style photoshoot blocking the stair path showed that the shared roof needed event and access rules.

The eventual booking rule validates the concern, not the unilateral closure used to force immediate attention.

Nothing was damaged, and you lacked authority to close the amenity to every resident for five days.

Could you have documented the blocked path and asked for an emergency committee vote without locking the roof?

Apologize for exceeding the key-holder role and publish the new booking process with a clear rule for actual safety closures.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →