Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for lending our community-hall key to a caterer without permission?

AITA category photographAITA

I volunteer as booking coordinator for our community hall and hold one of three keys. A caterer for Saturday’s wedding asked to enter Friday night to refrigerate food.

The rental began Saturday morning, and our policy allows keys only to named renters. The bride was traveling and could not collect one, so I lent mine to the caterer after checking his company ID.

On Friday night, a dance class arrived for its regular booking and found kitchen crates blocking an exit corridor. The instructor moved the crates outside, where several chilled desserts softened before the caterer returned.

The bride wants the hall to reimburse her. The committee says I created the conflict by granting unauthorized early access. I say I was trying to prevent food from sitting in a van overnight.

The caterer had asked whether the corridor could be used temporarily. I said yes without checking the floor plan because I assumed no Friday booking used the kitchen side.

I still have my coordinator role, but another volunteer now holds the key. The damaged desserts appear in every wedding photograph because the couple served them anyway.

Discussion

5 community replies

You granted access outside the rental period and approved corridor storage without checking another group’s active booking.

Verifying company ID addressed identity, not authority, timing or whether the corridor could be obstructed.

Protecting prepared food was a practical concern, but it required formal early access and a safe storage location.

Did the caterer have any alternative refrigeration plan if the hall could not be accessed Friday night?

Support a fair reimbursement decision and require written early-access approval plus a storage map for future events.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →