AITA for leaving my friend off a reservation after she would not confirm?
AITASeven friends planned dinner at a small restaurant. One friend, Paige, kept replying “probably” because her work schedule was uncertain.
The restaurant required an exact number and charged for empty seats. Two days before dinner, I booked for six and told Paige she could join only if someone canceled.
Her manager approved the evening off that afternoon. Paige messaged me immediately, but the restaurant said the table could not expand. I did not ask the group whether anyone would switch venues.
We went without her. She says the dinner had been planned around her birthday week and that I converted uncertainty into exclusion before the restaurant deadline.
I say everyone else confirmed and should not lose a hard-to-get table because one person could not commit.
Another nearby restaurant had space for seven at the same time. I dismissed it because the food was less special.
Paige saw our photographs in the group chat. Nobody had remembered to stop the automatic photo sharing.