Real people. Real opinions.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for leaving dinner when my friends revealed they had invited a surprise blind date?

AITA category photographAITA

Three friends invited me to dinner after I ended a long relationship. They said the evening was just our usual group and promised not to discuss dating.

When I arrived, a man named Eli was sitting in the fifth chair. I assumed he was someone’s coworker.

My friend Nora smiled and said, “We thought you two should meet.”

Eli looked as surprised as I felt. Apparently he had been told I knew the plan.

I stayed long enough to order water, then told everyone I was leaving. Eli apologized even though he had done nothing wrong. Nora asked me not to make the evening humiliating for him. I said the humiliation belonged to the people who had lied to both of us.

I left before the appetizers arrived.

Eli stayed for dinner. Later he sent a polite message saying he understood but had felt abandoned at a table of strangers who spent the first twenty minutes apologizing for me. I apologized to him directly.

My friends say walking out made the one innocent person absorb the consequence. They think I could have treated it as a group dinner, made no romantic commitment and confronted them afterward.

I think staying would have rewarded the setup and required me to perform ease for everyone who arranged it. Still, the person I intended to punish was surrounded by friends. The person I left was not.

I protected myself quickly and distributed the embarrassment badly.

Discussion

2 community replies

Both guests were lied to. Leaving was a reasonable refusal to perform a date, but Eli was the only person at the table without his own support system.

You did the important repair by apologizing to Eli directly. Your friends should also own that they used his time and dignity as part of their surprise.