Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for labeling my cousin’s potluck pie as store-bought?

AITA category photographAITA

Our family reunion included a dessert table and a playful “best homemade dish” vote. My cousin arrived with an apple pie on one of her ceramic plates and placed it among the entries.

I had seen the same pie in a bakery box in her car. I was organizing the table, so I wrote “Bakery apple pie — brought by Mia” on the card.

She changed it to “Mia’s apple pie.” I replaced my card and told her privately that a purchased pie could not enter the homemade vote. She left the dessert but went home before dinner.

My aunt says I publicly humiliated her over a silly contest. I say the label prevented everyone else from competing against a product she did not make.

Later I learned my cousin had baked the filling herself after buying an unbaked crust and assembled the pie in the bakery’s kitchen, where she works. The bakery box was simply what she had available.

Discussion

2 community replies

Protecting a homemade contest from a fully purchased entry would have been reasonable.

You treated a bakery box as proof and relabeled her work publicly before asking what she had made.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →