Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for keeping the refund from a canceled class gift?

AITA category photographAITA

Parents in my child’s class sent me money for a group gift: a pottery workshop for the teacher and her partner. I purchased a $400 voucher, including my $40 share.

The studio closed before the teacher used it. After several emails, I obtained a $320 refund; the remaining $80 was listed as a nonrefundable booking fee.

I kept the refund and bought the teacher a $320 bookstore card from the group. I did not tell the other parents until one asked about the studio.

They say the recovered money belonged to contributors and that a replacement gift required group approval. I say the money had already been given for the teacher’s benefit, not as a reversible purchase.

The teacher prefers books and thanked us warmly. Three parents still want their proportional refunds because they would not have chosen a bookstore card.

Returning about $32 to each household would have ended the group gift entirely. I decided preserving the gesture mattered more than reopening the decision.

The thank-you note names all ten families, including the three who now say the second gift was not from them.

Discussion

5 community replies

Using the recovered funds for an equivalent teacher gift preserved the original purpose and did not personally benefit you.

The teacher’s satisfaction supports the outcome but does not substitute for contributor consent to the replacement.

The original purchase failed, and you silently chose a different gift after contributors lost part of their money to the booking fee.

Was there time to poll the parents before buying the bookstore card, or did the refund carry an immediate deadline?

Offer proportional reimbursement to objecting parents from the remaining value you control, and require a group vote for future substitutions.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →