AITA for keeping the refund from a canceled class gift?
AITAParents in my child’s class sent me money for a group gift: a pottery workshop for the teacher and her partner. I purchased a $400 voucher, including my $40 share.
The studio closed before the teacher used it. After several emails, I obtained a $320 refund; the remaining $80 was listed as a nonrefundable booking fee.
I kept the refund and bought the teacher a $320 bookstore card from the group. I did not tell the other parents until one asked about the studio.
They say the recovered money belonged to contributors and that a replacement gift required group approval. I say the money had already been given for the teacher’s benefit, not as a reversible purchase.
The teacher prefers books and thanked us warmly. Three parents still want their proportional refunds because they would not have chosen a bookstore card.
Returning about $32 to each household would have ended the group gift entirely. I decided preserving the gesture mattered more than reopening the decision.
The thank-you note names all ten families, including the three who now say the second gift was not from them.