Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for keeping our entire utility refund after my roommate ran a space heater?

AITA category photographAITA

My roommate and I split electricity bills equally. Over winter, our bills doubled. She used a space heater in her bedroom most evenings, while I kept the main thermostat low.

We argued about the cost, but continued paying half each because we had no way to measure individual use.

In spring, the utility company corrected a meter error and issued a $280 refund to my account. I kept all of it. I told my roommate the refund offset the extra electricity her heater had probably consumed.

She says the correction applied to bills we both paid, so she is owed $140. She also says her room was colder because its window did not seal properly, something our landlord delayed repairing.

I calculated that the heater could have cost more than the full refund if used at its highest setting. I do not know its actual setting or hours, and the corrected bills do not identify the heater’s share.

My roommate offered to accept $100 rather than keep fighting. I refused because compromise felt like admitting her usage was unknowable.

It is unknowable. That is why we split the bills at the time, and also why I later felt free to assign the entire refund to myself.

Discussion

5 community replies

The refund corrected charges both roommates had paid equally. A later estimate cannot convert all shared overpayment into one person’s money.

The faulty window matters because some heater use addressed a housing defect rather than simply one roommate preferring excessive warmth.

Regular space-heater use likely increased consumption, and it was reasonable to discuss a different split while that use was happening.

Did you ever agree in writing that the heater user would pay more, or did every bill remain explicitly fifty-fifty?

Pay her half the refund and create a prospective utility agreement for unusual appliances instead of retroactively inventing one.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →