AITA for keeping my friend’s tool deposit after he returned the drill dirty?
AITAI lent a friend my cordless drill and asked for a $100 deposit because it was nearly new. We agreed I would return the money when the drill came back working.
He returned it on time and functional, but the case contained plaster dust and dried paint. I kept the full deposit and said professional cleaning plus reduced resale value justified it.
He offered to clean the drill himself or pay $25. I refused because I no longer trusted him to handle it carefully.
A repair shop later cleaned the drill for $30. There was no damage beneath the dust. I still kept the remaining $70 as compensation for having to inspect and arrange service.
My friend says the deposit was security, not a punishment fund. I say returning borrowed equipment dirty violates basic respect.
The drill looks new again. Our friendship now has a receipt for $30 and a disagreement worth $70.