AITA for keeping my friend’s projector after he canceled our screening?
AITAA friend lent me his projector for a neighborhood film night. The morning of the event, he canceled his attendance and asked me to return the projector because he wanted it for a game that evening.
I refused. Invitations had gone to thirty people, and I had already tested the setup. I said I would return it the next morning as originally discussed.
He came to my house before the screening and asked again. I did not open the door, though I could see him through the window.
The film night went well. He missed his game with friends because renting another projector cost more than they wanted to pay.
He says a loan can be withdrawn before use and that avoiding the door turned his property into leverage. I say he made a commitment that other people relied on.
Our messages did say “through Sunday morning,” but they also assumed he would attend the screening. His cancellation did not include an emergency; he simply preferred the game.
I returned the projector clean and on time. He sold it the following week rather than lend it to anyone again.