Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for keeping my friend’s projector after he canceled our screening?

AITA category photographAITA

A friend lent me his projector for a neighborhood film night. The morning of the event, he canceled his attendance and asked me to return the projector because he wanted it for a game that evening.

I refused. Invitations had gone to thirty people, and I had already tested the setup. I said I would return it the next morning as originally discussed.

He came to my house before the screening and asked again. I did not open the door, though I could see him through the window.

The film night went well. He missed his game with friends because renting another projector cost more than they wanted to pay.

He says a loan can be withdrawn before use and that avoiding the door turned his property into leverage. I say he made a commitment that other people relied on.

Our messages did say “through Sunday morning,” but they also assumed he would attend the screening. His cancellation did not include an emergency; he simply preferred the game.

I returned the projector clean and on time. He sold it the following week rather than lend it to anyone again.

Discussion

5 community replies

The written loan lasted through Sunday morning, and thirty invitees had reasonably relied on that arrangement.

Returning it on the original timetable supports your reliance argument but does not erase his direct demand before use.

The owner came in person before the event and revoked permission; refusing even to open the door escalated a favor into possession by force.

Could you have rented a replacement and asked him to cover part of the cost for breaking the commitment?

Acknowledge that ignoring the door crossed a line, and use rented equipment for events whose cancellation costs affect many people.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →