Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for keeping my friend’s cake deposit after she canceled?

AITA category photographAITA

A friend asked me to make a two-tier birthday cake with painted flowers. I bake from home on weekends, and she paid a $120 deposit toward a $240 total.

Thirty-six hours before pickup, she canceled the party because several guests were sick. By then I had baked the layers, made the filling and bought a custom topper with her mother’s name.

I told her the deposit was nonrefundable. She asked to apply it to a smaller cake next month, but I declined because the ingredients and most of my Saturday were already committed.

The problem is that I never sent a written cancellation policy. Our messages only say “deposit to hold the date.” She says a deposit is not automatically payment for a cake she never received.

I offered her the unfinished layers and topper. She did not want them, and I used the cake for decorating practice. We have not spoken since.

Discussion

3 community replies

The deposit covered a date and substantial work that could not be recovered after a late cancellation.

Calling it nonrefundable after the fact is unfair when your messages never stated that condition.

How much of the deposit reflects actual custom costs versus time you later used for practice?

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →