AITA for keeping a student’s phone during a field trip?
AITAA student used his phone repeatedly during a museum tour after two warnings. I confiscated it and said he could collect it when we returned to school.
During lunch, the phone rang several times. I silenced it without checking the caller.
His mother had been trying to say his younger sister was taken to the hospital after an accident. Another teacher learned through the school office an hour later.
The student says the behavior consequence should not have cut him off from urgent family contact. I say parents were instructed to call the school, not student devices, during the trip.
His mother had called the office first but reached voicemail during staff lunch. She then called his phone.
The student missed no required decision, but he lost an hour in which his family wanted him informed.