Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for keeping a package addressed to my apartment’s former tenant?

AITA category photographAITA

A package containing expensive cookware arrived addressed to the former tenant of my apartment. I messaged the landlord, who said he did not have current contact information.

The carrier refused to collect it because the tracking number showed successful delivery. I left it unopened in the lobby for two weeks, then brought it inside after another parcel disappeared.

Three months passed with no contact. I opened the box and began using the cookware.

The former tenant then appeared with proof of purchase. She had been disputing the delivery with the retailer and learned the address only after receiving an invoice copy. I returned the cookware, but several pans had scratches.

She wants replacement cost. I say I made reasonable efforts and stored the package safely for months. She says safe storage ended when I opened property bearing her name.

I had photographed the label and could have written “not at this address” before contacting the carrier again. I stopped trying because the box was taking up space.

The cookware is back with her. My old pans, which I donated after opening the box, are not back with me.

Discussion

5 community replies

You contacted the landlord and carrier and protected the package after theft in the lobby, which were reasonable initial steps.

Returning the scratched pans restored possession but not their original condition after your unauthorized use.

The former tenant’s name remained on the box; time and inconvenience did not convert the contents into your cookware.

Did the building have a return-to-sender area or management office that could have taken custody?

Pay a fair amount for the damage and refuse or return future former-tenant deliveries without opening them.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →