Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for keeping a donated guitar for my own child?

AITA category photographAITA

I volunteer at a charity shop. Someone donated a good acoustic guitar just before closing.

Our policy requires musical instruments to be assessed before sale. I knew my son wanted to learn, so I paid the expected shelf price of $75 into the register and took it home before appraisal.

The next day, a volunteer identified the guitar as a model worth several hundred dollars. The manager says I bypassed the assessment rule and cost the charity money.

I offered another $100 but refused to return it because my son had already begun using it. I say I paid honestly based on ordinary shop prices.

No price tag had been issued, and staff purchases are supposed to wait twenty-four hours after display.

My son practices every evening. The empty donation record lists the guitar as “sold before processing.”

Discussion

5 community replies

You used volunteer access to buy an unprocessed donation before appraisal and the required public waiting period.

Your son’s attachment developed only after the policy breach and does not settle what the charity lost.

You did pay rather than take it, but the amount was self-selected before the charity could value its property.

Would the charity accept the full appraised amount instead of requiring return?

Return the guitar or pay the charity’s documented fair price if management agrees.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →