AITA for keeping a donated guitar for my own child?
AITAI volunteer at a charity shop. Someone donated a good acoustic guitar just before closing.
Our policy requires musical instruments to be assessed before sale. I knew my son wanted to learn, so I paid the expected shelf price of $75 into the register and took it home before appraisal.
The next day, a volunteer identified the guitar as a model worth several hundred dollars. The manager says I bypassed the assessment rule and cost the charity money.
I offered another $100 but refused to return it because my son had already begun using it. I say I paid honestly based on ordinary shop prices.
No price tag had been issued, and staff purchases are supposed to wait twenty-four hours after display.
My son practices every evening. The empty donation record lists the guitar as “sold before processing.”