Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for hiding my friend’s car keys after her overnight shift?

AITA category photographAITA

My friend June came to breakfast after working an overnight hospital shift. She yawned through the meal and said she still had a forty-minute drive home.

I offered my sofa, a rideshare or a lift later. She refused all three and said she knew her own limits.

While she was in the restroom, I took her keys from the table and hid them in my kitchen drawer.

June searched for twenty minutes before I admitted it. She became furious and called a rideshare to a nearby hotel instead of staying with me. The room cost $140.

She says concern did not entitle me to take her property and trap her at my house. I say letting an exhausted friend drive after she rejected safer options would have made me complicit in a risk I could interrupt.

I did not claim to know precisely how impaired she was. I acted on what I saw: repeated yawning, slow answers and an overnight shift.

The part I handled badly was the hiding. I wanted her decision to disappear before we had another argument about it. She slept six hours at the hotel and sent me the bill.

Discussion

5 community replies

Repeated yawning and slowed conversation after an overnight shift gave the narrator a concrete reason to oppose a forty-minute drive.

Secretly taking the keys replaced persuasion with control and made the friend search before learning what had happened.

Holding the keys openly while arranging a safe handoff would still be serious, but more accountable than hiding them and waiting.

Was there another sober person who could assess the situation or drive June’s car home with her?

Offer to cover the hotel or rideshare cost, apologize for the deception and agree on an explicit plan before future post-shift meetings.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →