Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for giving my student’s reserved display space to a project that arrived early?

AITA category photographAITA

I coordinate a student design exhibition. Each finalist received a marked wall section and a 3 p.m. installation deadline.

One student, Hana, emailed at 2:20 saying the campus printer had jammed and that she would arrive around 3:15. At 2:45, another student brought an unexpectedly wide project that did not fit his assigned section.

I gave him Hana’s larger wall and moved her label to a narrow corner. She arrived at 3:08 with her prints. They had to be stacked vertically, which broke the sequence she had designed.

Hana says she warned me and still arrived only eight minutes after the deadline. I say exhibitions require punctuality and I could not leave a strong project on the floor.

The other student had ignored the dimensions in the installation guide. I rewarded that mistake with more space because he was physically present.

Judges praised his work and noted that Hana’s sequence was hard to follow. He won the exhibition prize.

I enforced the clock against the person whose delay was seven minutes shorter than she predicted, then called the resulting wall arrangement neutral.

Discussion

5 community replies

You rewarded a project that violated size requirements by taking space from a student who communicated and arrived only eight minutes late.

The judges’ result was not neutral because your placement decisions improved one presentation and impaired the other.

A firm installation deadline can be legitimate, but consequences should be defined before problems occur and applied consistently.

Could the oversized project have been reconfigured or placed in the narrow corner instead of displacing Hana’s planned sequence?

Document the display change for the judges, offer Hana a corrected showing and enforce published dimensions at future installations.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →