Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for giving my sister’s pottery kiln slot to someone who arrived early?

AITA category photographAITA

I manage bookings for a community pottery studio. My sister reserved the large kiln for 6 p.m. to fire pieces for a weekend craft sale.

At 6:10, she had not arrived or answered my message. Another member was waiting with a full load and offered to start immediately. I gave him the slot.

My sister arrived at 6:18. She had been unloading boxes from her car and had left her phone inside one of them. The other firing would occupy the kiln until morning, too late for her glazing schedule.

She says I knew she was in the building parking lot because her car was visible from the studio window. I had seen a similar car but did not go outside to check.

Studio policy allows cancellation after fifteen minutes, not ten. I knew that, but I wanted the kiln running rather than idle while someone prepared to use it.

The early member offered to remove his unfired pieces, but I said changing course twice would be unfair to him.

My sister attended the sale with half her planned inventory. The kiln ran efficiently. My application of its rules did not.

Discussion

5 community replies

The written grace period was fifteen minutes, and you reassigned the kiln after ten while your sister was already in the parking lot.

The replacement member’s offer to step back provided a chance to correct the premature reassignment before any firing began.

Keeping expensive shared equipment active is a legitimate studio goal, but it cannot override published booking rules selectively.

Were members required to check in at the desk before unloading, or could arrival reasonably include bringing pieces from the car?

Refund or credit the lost slot, acknowledge the policy breach and use an automatic fifteen-minute timer for every future booking.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →