AITA for giving my mother the upstairs room at our reunion after she requested the quiet one?
AITAI booked a large rental house for a family reunion and collected equal shares from six households. The listing showed four bedrooms downstairs and two upstairs.
My mother asked for the quietest room because she wakes easily. I assigned her the upstairs room at the end of the hall and gave the downstairs rooms to families with young children.
When we arrived, we learned the staircase was steep and the upstairs bathroom was across a landing. My mother can climb stairs, but slowly, and she had to plan every trip. She said she would rather take the smaller room beside the kitchen.
My brother had already unpacked his children there and refused to move them. I told my mother the arrangement was set and reminded her that she had asked for quiet.
She spent most of the weekend upstairs and skipped breakfast twice. On the last night, my brother admitted his children slept through anything and could have managed upstairs.
I thought I was honoring the one preference she stated. Once I saw what that preference cost her, I protected my room chart instead of asking everyone to reconsider.
The upstairs room was silent. So was her seat at two breakfasts.