Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for donating the baby supplies my friend left at my house after postponing her shower?

AITA category photographAITA

I offered my apartment for my friend Nia’s baby shower. Boxes of decorations, diapers and unopened gifts arrived during the week before it.

Two days before the shower, Nia was placed on bed rest and postponed the event indefinitely. I told her the boxes could stay for a month because I needed the room for visiting relatives after that.

Six weeks later, the supplies were still there. Nia’s partner had canceled two pickup times. I sent a final message saying I would clear the room that Saturday. He replied with a thumbs-up, which I read as agreement.

I donated the diapers and toiletries to a family shelter and discarded the personalized decorations. I kept the wrapped gifts together for Nia.

Her partner arrived Sunday with a borrowed van. He says his thumbs-up meant he had seen the deadline, not that I could give things away. Some diaper boxes had been purchased by guests from Nia’s registry, and she had planned to use them after the birth.

I thought donating essentials was better than putting them outside. I also could have moved everything into my bedroom for one more day, but I was tired of every revised plan becoming my storage problem.

My relatives now have a clear room. Nia has a list of supplies she says I owe her.

Discussion

5 community replies

Six weeks and two missed pickups exceeded the month of storage you offered, so setting a firm clearing date was reasonable.

A thumbs-up acknowledged the message; it did not clearly transfer ownership of gifts and supplies meant for an imminent birth.

Keeping the wrapped gifts shows you recognized some items remained Nia’s property, which makes the different treatment of diapers harder to justify.

Did your final message explicitly say the usable supplies would be donated, or only that you would clear the room?

Replace the donated registry items you can identify, then set written pickup terms before accepting storage for anyone again.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →