Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for donating our family letters to an archive without asking my siblings?

AITA category photographAITA

I inherited a box of letters written by my grandparents during the 1950s. The will left the box to me, while my siblings received other keepsakes.

A local historical archive asked to preserve and digitize the letters. I signed a permanent donation agreement because the box was deteriorating in my closet.

When I told my siblings, one asked for our grandmother’s courtship letters and another wanted the originals kept private until our parents had died. The archive had already cataloged the first folder.

I say the will made the letters mine and professional storage protects them. My siblings say the pages contain family stories, medical worries and arguments involving people who never agreed to public research access.

The archive offered to restrict access for ten years but will not return the collection under the agreement I signed.

I had not read every letter before donating them. I believed their historical value came partly from being unfiltered.

The box is now safer than it has been in decades. My family feels less safe about what is inside it.

Discussion

5 community replies

The will gave you the collection, and professional preservation addressed real deterioration that private storage had not solved.

Ownership of the paper did not remove the ethical privacy interests of living people discussed in the letters.

You permanently donated unread family correspondence containing other people’s private lives before even notifying close relatives.

Did the archive explain access restrictions and withdrawal limits before you signed, including options for sensitive folders?

Accept the ten-year restriction now and work with family and archivists to identify sensitive folders for longer limits if available.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →