Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for donating my coworker’s birthday cake after she canceled the party?

AITA category photographAITA

Our office ordered a large birthday cake for a coworker. She went home sick before lunch and asked us to keep it in the refrigerator until she returned.

The cake box filled most of the shelf, and our office closed for a three-day weekend. I donated it that afternoon to a nearby community meal service.

My coworker returned Tuesday and was upset. Her sister had ordered the cake from a bakery she loved, and she had planned to take it home for a family dinner.

I say the cake would have been four days old and feeding people that day was better than letting it sit. She says I did not own it and could have called her sister for pickup.

I had her sister’s number in the order email but did not notice it until later. The meal service sent a thank-you photograph showing the cake already cut.

My coworker has printed that photograph and placed it beside the empty refrigerator shelf.

Discussion

4 community replies

A large perishable cake before a long closure created a real storage and freshness problem.

The donation was generous toward recipients but used someone else’s property to create that generosity.

The owner explicitly asked for it to be kept, and the order email provided a family contact who could have collected it.

Did the office refrigerator actually need the shelf during the closure, or was space only a general concern?

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →