Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for cutting the lock off a bicycle left on my rack for a week?

AITA category photographAITA

A bicycle appeared locked to the rack beside my townhouse. The rack is on my property and holds only two bikes.

I posted a note asking the owner to remove it within three days. After seven days, it was still there. I cut the cable lock and moved the bicycle into my shed so my child could use the rack.

That evening, a neighbor from two streets away knocked on my door. Her son had ridden the bike to a nearby bus stop, then left town with his school group. He had mistaken my rack for a public one.

I returned the bicycle but refused to pay for a new lock. I say I gave clear notice and protected the bike by storing it rather than leaving it loose.

She says a teenager away on a trip could not see my note, and I could have asked in the neighborhood chat before destroying anything.

The rack has no address sign and sits beside the sidewalk. I had always considered its location obviously private because it matches my fence.

My child’s bike occupied the freed space for one afternoon. The cut lock remains on my workbench.

Discussion

5 community replies

An unknown bike occupied half of a private rack for a week, so eventually moving it was reasonable.

Storing the bicycle protected it after removal, but that does not erase the avoidable cost of cutting the lock.

The rack’s sidewalk location was ambiguous, and a neighborhood message could have identified the owner before destroying the lock.

Did the warning note state that the lock would be cut, or merely ask for removal?

Replace the lock and add a clear private-rack sign before taking stronger action against any future bicycle.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →