AITA for choosing the losing logo but crediting the contest winner?
AITAOur volunteer sports club held a logo contest. Members voted for a detailed crest submitted by one teenager. A simpler design from another student placed second.
The printer said the winning crest would blur on small uniforms. I used the second-place design but announced that the winner had created the club’s new visual identity.
The second student recognized her shapes and color arrangement. She says I used her work while giving the title and public praise to someone else.
I say the contest promised recognition to the vote winner, while production required adaptation. The final logo contains a small element from the winning crest.
I had not asked either student to collaborate. I combined the files myself and listed only the winner in the launch post.
The uniforms look clear. The two students no longer attend the same club meetings.