Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for charging my houseguest for a window broken during a storm?

AITA category photographAITA

A friend stayed in my guest room for a week. Before leaving for dinner, she opened the window because the room felt warm.

A sudden storm arrived while we were out. Wind slammed the window against its frame and cracked the glass. Rain also damaged the curtain and part of the wooden sill.

I asked my friend to pay the full $480 repair bill because she had opened the window. She offered half, saying neither of us had checked the weather and I had never told her the latch was loose.

I refused and kept the $300 she had transferred earlier toward our shared concert tickets. I then asked for the remaining $180.

The repair technician said a secure latch should have held an open window in ordinary wind, though this storm had unusually strong gusts. I had noticed the latch slipping before but had not repaired it.

My friend says I used money meant for another purpose to assign blame before we understood the cause. I say the glass would be intact if she had closed the window.

We both missed the concert. The repaired window now has a new latch.

Discussion

5 community replies

Leaving a window open before a storm contributed to the damage, so some shared responsibility is reasonable.

The open window was part of the chain, but “it would be intact otherwise” does not establish that one person owes the full repair.

You knew the latch slipped and seized unrelated ticket money before the technician clarified that the fixture itself was deficient.

Did the weather change unexpectedly after you left, or was a storm already forecast when the window was opened?

Return the ticket money, accept the offered half if fair and treat the latch upgrade as your property cost.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →