AITA for charging my houseguest for a window broken during a storm?
AITAA friend stayed in my guest room for a week. Before leaving for dinner, she opened the window because the room felt warm.
A sudden storm arrived while we were out. Wind slammed the window against its frame and cracked the glass. Rain also damaged the curtain and part of the wooden sill.
I asked my friend to pay the full $480 repair bill because she had opened the window. She offered half, saying neither of us had checked the weather and I had never told her the latch was loose.
I refused and kept the $300 she had transferred earlier toward our shared concert tickets. I then asked for the remaining $180.
The repair technician said a secure latch should have held an open window in ordinary wind, though this storm had unusually strong gusts. I had noticed the latch slipping before but had not repaired it.
My friend says I used money meant for another purpose to assign blame before we understood the cause. I say the glass would be intact if she had closed the window.
We both missed the concert. The repaired window now has a new latch.