Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for billing my coworker after her muddy shoes stained my car during our carpool?

AITA category photographAITA

I drive three coworkers to the office twice a week. Everyone contributes toward parking and fuel.

After a rainy morning, one coworker, Mina, climbed in with muddy boots. I had placed towels on the floor, but she pushed one aside and mud stained the light carpet near her seat.

I had the car professionally detailed for $160 and asked Mina to pay the full bill. She offered $60, saying the service cleaned the entire interior, including stains and crumbs that were already there.

I refused and removed her from the carpool until she paid. The other riders now contribute more, and Mina takes two buses.

The detailer’s receipt lists only “full interior service”; it does not separate the muddy area. I chose the premium package because the basic spot clean did not include seat shampoo, which I had wanted for months.

I say her carelessness triggered an expense I would not have booked that week. She says I used her footprint to finance maintenance the whole car needed.

The carpet is clean. So are the seats she never touched.

Discussion

5 community replies

Mina moved a protective towel and caused a visible stain, so contributing to the cleanup is reasonable.

Her mistake triggered the appointment, but triggering a purchase does not make her responsible for every benefit bundled into it.

The premium detail included old seat and interior cleaning you already wanted, making the full $160 an inflated charge.

What did the detailer quote for cleaning only the muddy carpet, even if that option was less convenient?

Accept the cost of a reasonable spot clean from Mina and pay the upgrade difference yourself before restoring the carpool.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →