Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for barring my neighbor’s child from my piano before her scholarship audition?

AITA category photographAITA

My downstairs neighbor’s thirteen-year-old, Elise, practices on my piano twice a week because her family only has a small keyboard. She has a music scholarship audition next month.

Last Tuesday, I found two chipped keys and a drink ring on the bench. Elise admitted that she had brought a friend upstairs and let him try the instrument while I was at work. My rule had always been that only she could play and no drinks were allowed.

I canceled her access until the keys are repaired. The technician cannot come for three weeks, four days before her audition.

Her mother offered to pay immediately and supervise every remaining practice. I refused because the consequence would mean nothing if Elise returned the next day.

Her teacher says the weighted keys matter for her preparation and asked whether I could allow one supervised session a week. I said no.

I am not responsible for her scholarship chances. Still, I chose a punishment whose length is determined by my technician’s calendar, not by the damage or a date I set.

Elise left an apology note under my door. I have not answered it. Every afternoon I hear her practice the same passage on the thin keyboard below me.

Discussion

5 community replies

Elise broke two clear conditions and allowed another person to use a valuable instrument, so suspending unsupervised access was justified.

A consequence can remain meaningful if access returns only under direct adult supervision and stricter rules.

Her mother offered payment and supervision. Refusing any controlled practice makes the scholarship audition part of the punishment rather than protecting the piano.

Did the technician say the chipped keys make playing unsafe or likely to cause further damage before the repair?

Allow limited supervised sessions if the piano is playable, and make repair payment plus a no-guests agreement conditions of future access.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →