Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for banning my nephew from my home library after he damaged a book?

AITA category photographAITA

My twelve-year-old nephew borrowed an illustrated book from my home library. He returned it with a drink stain across several pages.

He apologized and offered $20 from his allowance. The book is out of print and a similar copy costs about $90.

I accepted the $20 but told him he could no longer enter the library or borrow anything until he was eighteen. My sister says a six-year ban is punishment for an accident he immediately owned.

I say the collection includes fragile books and trust matters more than the replacement price.

The stain happened when his younger brother knocked over a cup. My nephew had left the book open on the kitchen table despite my rule to read it only in the living room.

He now waits in the hallway when cousins choose books. The stained volume is still readable on my shelf.

Discussion

5 community replies

He ignored a clear location rule and exposed a scarce book to avoidable damage.

Protecting rare books does not require excluding him from the entire room until adulthood.

A six-year blanket ban ignores his immediate apology, partial repayment and the younger child’s role in the accident.

Could supervised reading or borrowing ordinary books restore trust gradually?

Create a supervised-access period and reserve strict restrictions for rare volumes rather than all books.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →