Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for awarding the choir solo to the donor instead of the audition winner?

AITA category photographAITA

I direct a community choir that is raising money to replace its risers. One member, Helen, offered a $5,000 matching donation if our winter concert reached capacity.

We held auditions for a featured solo. A younger member, Priya, received the highest scores from the three-person panel. Helen ranked third.

Our board chair suggested giving Helen the solo because her family could fill a large section of the hall and her donation had kept the concert affordable. I agreed and told Priya the panel had chosen a voice with a more traditional tone.

Priya later saw the score sheets while helping file music. She asked why the result had been changed. I admitted the board had considered fundraising.

Helen says she never tied her gift to the solo and would have donated anyway. She is now embarrassed and has offered to step aside. The concert programs have already been printed with her name.

I thought one artistic compromise protected the whole choir. Instead, I attributed the decision to taste because saying “money” aloud sounded as improper as it now looks.

Priya remains in the choir but no longer sings the solo line during rehearsal.

Discussion

5 community replies

You held a scored audition, overrode the result for fundraising reasons, then gave Priya a false artistic explanation.

Helen’s statement that she never requested the solo removes even the claim that this compromise was necessary to secure her donation.

A volunteer director must consider attendance and finances, but those criteria needed to be disclosed before anyone auditioned.

Did the board have authority under the choir’s rules to override the panel, or was this an informal suggestion you accepted?

Restore the solo to Priya, correct the program verbally or with an insert, and publish selection criteria before the next audition.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →