Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Stories & Confessions ·

A street musician thinks my weekly song request honors someone who died

Stories & Confessions category photographStories & Confessions

Every Tuesday, a guitarist plays outside my train station.

After a difficult breakup, I asked him to play the song my former partner and I used to sing in the car. I tipped him twenty dollars and cried through half of it.

The next Tuesday, he played it when he saw me. I tipped him again.

This continued for months. He never asked for the story, and I never offered it.

Last week, another commuter told me how moving it was that the musician honored my late husband every Tuesday. She had heard him describe the song as “for someone our regular is missing.”

I am not widowed. My ex lives three neighborhoods away and recently got engaged.

The guitarist was mortified when I corrected him. He wants to announce the truth next week so people do not keep donating to a false memorial. I would prefer that my breakup not become a station update.

Can he retire the story without explaining exactly who the song was—and was not—for?

Discussion

5 community replies

Yes. “I misunderstood a private request, so I’m not telling that story anymore” is enough. Your breakup does not owe the platform a correction speech.

He should stop describing it as a memorial, especially if listeners are tipping because they believe someone died.

Missing a living person can produce the same public tears as grief. The commuters filled in details neither of you actually gave them.

You could keep requesting the song with no dedication at all, or choose a new one that belongs to your Tuesday routine rather than the relationship.

Which song carries a story that strangers would probably guess completely wrong?

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Stories & Confessions

Explore more Stories & Confessions stories →