Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Parenting ·

A painted rock became an engagement story before either child agreed to one

Parenting category photographParenting

My five-year-old gave a girl at the park a painted rock. She liked it and put it in her pocket.

On the way home he said they were getting married because she'd accepted it.

His grandmother laughed and asked whether she needed to buy a hat. I laughed too. Then my son asked whether the girl would have to give the rock back if she changed her mind.

The grown-ups had helped turn a present into an agreement while enjoying how cute the story sounded.

I said giving her the rock hadn't made a plan for both of them. He said she had said yes. I asked what she'd said yes to. He said he'd asked whether she wanted the rock.

There was the entire negotiation, considerably smaller than the family had made it.

He still wants to play with her next time. That's something he can ask when they meet. I don't need to discuss their imaginary future with her parent or repeat the marriage story while the children stand beside us.

Grandma said she was only joking. I told her I knew, but he was already trying to work out which obligations came with his present.

He has painted another rock for himself. He says it means he can keep his own favorite color. That sounds like a more manageable arrangement, although I've stopped offering commentary about what any of the rocks predict.

Discussion

5 community replies

She agreed to receive a rock. Asking exactly what he had asked exposed the extra agreement the adults were helping him imagine.

Grandma may genuinely have heard it as harmless pretend play. The question about returning the rock showed your son had taken part of it more literally.

You can respond to that question without turning Grandma's affection into the problem. Stop extending the story now that you know how he's interpreting it.

Had your son mentioned marriage to the girl at all, or only to the family afterward? There's no reason to involve her in a conversation she never had.

Keep the next invitation about the play he actually wants. She can accept or decline that invitation without the painted gift becoming a bargaining piece.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Parenting

Explore more Parenting stories →